When it comes to starting your day right, nothing hits the spot quite like a well-crafted breakfast sandwich. Whether you're a local or just passing through New York, these spots are serving up some of the most mouthwatering breakfast creations you'll ever sink your teeth into. From classic combos to unique twists, here are ten must-try breakfast sandwiches that will make your morning in New York unforgettable. These are HVH's top picks—check them out and savor the best breakfast sandwiches the region has to offer!
1. Crafted Kup - Poughkeepsie, NY @craftedkup Start your day on a high note with Crafted Kup’s famous croissant breakfast sandwich. This beauty begins with a buttery, flaky house-made croissant, filled with two fresh-baked eggs, crispy bacon, and melted cheddar cheese. But that’s not all—add creamy sliced avocado, a hint of garlic and herb cream cheese, and a drizzle of their signature chipotle mayo. Every bite is a burst of flavor, making it a breakfast experience you won’t want to miss.
2. Sugar & Spice Cafe - Poughkeepsie, NY @sugarandspicecafe For those who like a bit of a kick in the morning, Sugar & Spice Cafe has you covered. Their Breakfast Sandwich Special is a tantalizing mix of two fried eggs, pepper jack cheese, crispy bacon, and avocado, all smothered in a zesty chipotle pesto. Served on a flaky croissant, this sandwich is perfect for breakfast, brunch, or any time you crave something deliciously satisfying.
3. The Beacon Daily - Beacon, NY @thebeacondaily The Beacon Daily takes the classic breakfast sandwich and elevates it to new heights. Their English Muffin Breakfast Sandwich features a buttery toasted house-made English muffin, two eggs, and two slices of hardwood-smoked bacon, with melty American cheese to bring it all together. Customize it with house-made chorizo, maple sausage, and a side of crispy hash browns or tots. This is the breakfast sandwich you’ll want every day of the week.
4. Bella's Bake Shop - Mount Kisco, NY @bellasbakeshopny Bella's Bake Shop brings a touch of elegance to the breakfast sandwich game with their smoked salmon creation. Picture this: a freshly baked round croissant, seasoned with everything bagel spices, stuffed with rich cream cheese, creamy avocado, and smoky salmon. It’s the perfect blend of savory flavors and luxurious textures to kickstart your morning in the most delicious way possible.
5. Red Line Diner - Fishkill, NY @redlinediner Voted New York’s “Best Diner,” Red Line Diner delivers with their Tex-Mex Wrap, a fan-favorite breakfast sandwich. This hearty wrap is packed with eggs, grilled onions, peppers, chorizo, home fries, and cheese. Pair it with their seasonal mimosa flight for a breakfast experience that’s as indulgent as it is flavorful.
6. Countryside Kitchen - Mahopac, NY @countryside_kitchen Countryside Kitchen serves breakfast all day, and their signature Frenchie sandwich is a standout. Imagine two eggs, crispy bacon, and melted cheese sandwiched between slices of old-fashioned French toast. It’s the ultimate sweet and savory breakfast combo that’s perfect for satisfying your morning cravings.
7. Moonrise Bagels - Woodstock & Poughkeepsie, NY @moonrisebagels Moonrise Bagels is known nationwide for their signature stuffed bagels, and once you try one, you’ll see why. Their Bacon, Egg & Cheese stuffed bagel is a fan favorite, hand-rolled, boiled, baked, and filled with comfort food goodness. With vegetarian and vegan options available, there’s something for everyone at this New York gem.
8. Royal Crepes - Beacon, NY @royalcrepesbeacon Royal Crepes offers a unique twist on the breakfast sandwich with their Smoked Aged Beef Sausage, Grilled Vegetable Spread, Egg and Cheese Crepe. It’s one of seven breakfast crepes they offer, each one packed with flavor and made to order. This crepe is a savory delight that’s perfect for breakfast or brunch.
9. Fiddlestix Cafe - Cornwall, NY @fiddlestixcafe Fiddlestix Cafe knows how to do breakfast right with their double-egg bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich. Served on a buttered and toasted Kaiser roll, this sandwich is topped with house-seasoned home fries and melted American cheese. It’s comfort food at its finest, with a little SPK (salt, pepper, ketchup) to top it all off.
10. Mornings Cafe - Arkville, NY @cafe_mornings For something a little different, head to Mornings Cafe for their Korean Style Toast Sandwich. Made with Mornings' signature corn-cheese furikake scrambled egg patties, brioche buns, and a special kewpie mayo ketchup glaze, this sandwich is a flavor explosion. Customize it with your choice of avocado, bacon, or ham for a breakfast that’s as unique as it is delicious.
Whether you’re in the mood for something classic or adventurous, these breakfast sandwiches from around New York are sure to satisfy. Each one is crafted with care and bursting with flavor, making them the perfect way to start your day. So, next time you’re in the area, be sure to give these spots a try—you won’t be disappointed!
